<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="226" public="1" featured="0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://mtcwia.com/items/show/226?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-11-19T04:40:08+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="331">
      <src>https://mtcwia.com/files/original/b869f49e70cf709a8cdc43c4579b96a5.pdf</src>
      <authentication>087ae2e36681a490148c9500152c3faf</authentication>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="6">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="6">
                <text>Books</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <itemType itemTypeId="1">
    <name>Text</name>
    <description>A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.</description>
    <elementContainer>
      <element elementId="1">
        <name>Text</name>
        <description>Any textual data included in the document</description>
        <elementTextContainer>
          <elementText elementTextId="1273">
            <text>University of Virginia Press&#13;
Chapter Title: Abolitionism as Logical Conclusion: General James S. Wadsworth as a Case Study in Anti-Southern Sentiment and the Radicalizing Experience of the Civil War&#13;
Chapter Author(s): Judith A. Hunter&#13;
Book Title: The Struggle for Equality&#13;
Book Subtitle: Essays on Sectional Conflict, the Civil War, and the Long Reconstruction&#13;
Book Editor(s): Orville Vernon Burton, Jerald Podair, Jennifer L. Weber&#13;
Published by: University of Virginia Press. (2011)&#13;
Stable URL: https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt6wrmq5.6&#13;
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a widerange of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity andfacilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms &amp; Conditions of Use, available athttps://about.jstor.org/terms&#13;
University of Virginia Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend&#13;
access to The Struggle for Equality&#13;
This content downloaded from 129.174.21.5 on Thu, 17 Jun 2021 00:14:22 UTC&#13;
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms&#13;
Abolitionism as Logical Conclusion&#13;
General James S. Wadsworth as a Case Study&#13;
in Anti-Southern Sentiment and the Radicalizing&#13;
Experience of the Civil War&#13;
E E E&#13;
Judith A. Hunter&#13;
When James S. Wadsworth, a prominent Union general well-known for&#13;
his military exploits, his politics, and his background, died after the&#13;
battle of the Wilderness in 1864, it moved a North that had seen all too many&#13;
deaths. In fact, John Hay remarked that Abraham Lincoln felt the loss of&#13;
Wadsworth keenly:&#13;
I have not known the President so a√ected by a personal loss since the death&#13;
of [Colonel Edward D.] Baker, as by the death of General Wadsworth. . . .&#13;
[Lincoln said that] no man has given himself up to the war with such selfsacrificing&#13;
patriotism as Gen. Wadsworth. He went into the service not wishing&#13;
or expecting great success or distinction in his military career and profoundly&#13;
indi√erent to popular applause, actuated only by a sense of duty&#13;
which he neither evaded nor sought to evade.∞&#13;
Lincoln’s respect and the public’s acclaim for Wadsworth were shaped in&#13;
large part by the fact that he had immediately volunteered for the war, leaving&#13;
behind an enormous agricultural empire in western New York, serving without&#13;
pay, and volunteering to start as close to the bottom as a prominent man in&#13;
his fifties could, as a major. Quickly promoted to brigadier general for both his&#13;
service at Bull Run and his eminence in New York politics, Wadsworth was&#13;
passionate in his defense of the Union and his opposition to slavery.≤ However,&#13;
his abolitionist feelings were an endpoint in a long process, one that&#13;
modern biographers have not examined. It was a process that is illustrative of&#13;
how feelings about slavery in the North gradually changed and hardened in&#13;
response to events, especially the experience of the Civil War itself.&#13;
This content downloaded from 129.174.21.5 on Thu, 17 Jun 2021 00:14:22 UTC&#13;
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms&#13;
30 Judith A. Hunter&#13;
Because Wadsworth’s endpoint was as a member of the faction of the&#13;
Republican Party known as the Radicals, it has been tempting for scholars to&#13;
assume that he always had radical positions on the subject of slavery. Yet that&#13;
characterization does not accurately describe Wadsworth’s beliefs for most of&#13;
his life. Although he left scant records to examine, those that survive show no&#13;
concern for the condition of slaves or indignation at the immorality of slavery&#13;
until after the war had begun. Wadsworth had had a long political career in&#13;
the antebellum period, and what prompted him to speak out in the 1840s and&#13;
1850s was not so much slavery as ‘‘the slave power.’’ Wadsworth became&#13;
convinced, as did many Northerners during the antebellum period, that a&#13;
cabal of powerful proslavery Southerners was endangering the freedoms and&#13;
very existence of the republic in their zeal to protect and promote the institution&#13;
of slavery. This conviction, more than concern about slavery’s iniquity,&#13;
was his main motivation.≥&#13;
The first event to goad James Wadsworth toward antislavery had more to&#13;
do with political infighting among Democrats than anything else. Although&#13;
his father, the founder of the family fortune and his hometown, was, unsurprisingly,&#13;
a Whig, James S. Wadsworth’s earliest known political allegiances&#13;
were to the Democrats and to Martin Van Buren. He was outraged&#13;
when Martin Van Buren was, as the young Wadsworth saw it, cheated out of&#13;
the Democratic nomination in 1844. Instead, the Democrats chose James K.&#13;
Polk, primarily because Van Buren had come out against the annexation of&#13;
Texas (which, all sides assumed, would add vast new slave territories to the&#13;
United States and provoke war with Mexico). Wadsworth wrote a livid letter&#13;
to the former president after the nominating convention: ‘‘I have seen no full&#13;
account of the debates, but I do not perceive that the dictation and selfishness&#13;
of the South were properly rebuked. They have filled the Executive Chair 44&#13;
years, the North 12, and yet because we are not prepared to embark in a most&#13;
unjust and iniquitous war to extend their ‘Institutions’—meaning Slavery—&#13;
our rights are again to be deferred.’’∂&#13;
Had Wadsworth’s primary political concerns revolved around slavery at&#13;
this point, he could have supported the third-party candidacy of the Liberty&#13;
Party’s James G. Birney, who garnered enough votes in western New York to&#13;
help throw the state into Polk’s column in the 1844 election. There is no&#13;
record of Wadsworth’s having done so. In fact, he expressed approval of Polk&#13;
as vice-presidential material in the same letter to Van Buren, saying, ‘‘I have a&#13;
favourable opinion of Mr. Polk and hoped to have seen him nominated, but&#13;
not where he is.’’ Antiquarian accounts suggest Wadsworth became reconciled&#13;
enough to Polk to support his presidential candidacy and place wagers&#13;
on his victory.Σ&#13;
A sense of outraged honor, in this case that Van Buren had been unfairly&#13;
This content downloaded from 129.174.21.5 on Thu, 17 Jun 2021 00:14:22 UTC&#13;
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms&#13;
Abolitionism as Logical Conclusion 31&#13;
deprived of the Democratic presidential nomination by scheming Southerners,&#13;
often seemed to motivate Wadsworth to take his strongest political&#13;
positions. He was not at all typical of most of the Van Buren supporters who&#13;
split from the New York Democracy. Jonathan Earle’s careful examination of&#13;
Northern Democrats who pushed for the limitation of slavery to its existing&#13;
boundaries (‘‘Free Soilers’’) demonstrates that Van Buren’s defenders in New&#13;
York typically came from a very di√erent background than James Wadsworth&#13;
did. They tended to come from rural areas that were economically stagnant&#13;
and isolated; he finds them to have been outside the economically, politically,&#13;
socially, and religiously fertile area of upstate New York historians refer to&#13;
as the ‘‘burned-over district.’’ Although there is no evidence that suggests&#13;
Wadsworth took part in the religious or social ‘‘enthusiasms’’ of his region,&#13;
they surrounded him in the prosperous Genesee Valley, a part of the burnedover&#13;
district. His great wealth and its source were also unusual for the ‘‘Barnburners’’&#13;
(New York Democrats who bolted their party to remain loyal to Van&#13;
Buren). Earle finds that many of them were involved in the antirent agitations&#13;
against large landholders that characterized rural New York in this period, so&#13;
Wadsworth’s role as a land baron made him a most anomalous Barnburner.Π&#13;
Henry B. Stanton recounts an anecdote in his memoirs about Wadsworth’s&#13;
activities as a Barnburner that strongly hints that Wadsworth was&#13;
chiefly motivated by his feelings of indignation rather than an ideological&#13;
position on slavery. Bitter recriminations between the Barnburners and their&#13;
rivals, the ‘‘Hunkers,’’ marked the 1847 New York Democratic convention in&#13;
Syracuse. The Hunkers’ treatment the previous year of Silas Wright, the&#13;
unsuccessful Barnburner candidate for governor, had angered Wadsworth’s&#13;
faction. Wright’s death just a short time later increased the bitter feelings. As&#13;
Stanton recalled, James Wadsworth dramatically and physically let everyone&#13;
know whom he held responsible for their leader’s demise: ‘‘In the convention&#13;
some one spoke of doing justice to Silas Wright. A Hunker sneeringly responded,&#13;
‘It is too late; he is dead.’ Springing upon a table, Wadsworth made&#13;
the hall ring as he uttered a defiant reply: ‘Though it may be too late to do&#13;
justice to Silas Wright, it is not too late to do justice to his assassins.’ ’’π&#13;
The slight to Van Buren ended up permanently dividing New York Democrats,&#13;
who had di≈culty working together from that point. The Barnburners,&#13;
Wadsworth’s faction, bolted the 1848 Democratic national convention&#13;
over the Wilmot Proviso (a free soil measure they supported and the national&#13;
party did not) and spurned the nominee, Lewis Cass, in favor of Van Buren,&#13;
whom they helped to put at the head of the third-party Free Soil ticket.&#13;
Wadsworth’s public statements on the issue prompted the Maryland politician&#13;
Francis Preston Blair to write him approvingly, commending him for&#13;
avoiding even the appearance of abolitionism: ‘‘You make an admirable dis-&#13;
This content downloaded from 129.174.21.5 on Thu, 17 Jun 2021 00:14:22 UTC&#13;
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms&#13;
32 Judith A. Hunter&#13;
tinction when you point the attention to the fact that the true Democrats of&#13;
the country aim to extend its prosperity by providing for the white race, whilst&#13;
abolitionism is only concerned for the black.’’ Blair continued in a vein that&#13;
made it clear that he did not consider James Wadsworth to be a radical in any&#13;
way on the subject of slavery: ‘‘The truth is that the abolitionists and the&#13;
slave propaganders [sic] are much nearer allies in their sympathies than we&#13;
with either. They are both Negro lovers—the first because they are political&#13;
property—the second because they are personal property.’’∫&#13;
Another strong indication that James Wadsworth was not deeply and&#13;
personally concerned with actual slaves, rather than the expansion of slavery,&#13;
comes from his philanthropic activity during the antebellum period. Wadsworth&#13;
was renowned for his support of charitable causes. For instance, during&#13;
the height of the Irish potato famine, he provided a full shipload of grain to&#13;
the famine relief e√ort. In the 1850s he donated sums of three to five thousand&#13;
dollars annually to benevolent organizations. Yet Wadsworth was noticeably&#13;
inactive in funding antislavery e√orts. The only exceptions were fifty dollars&#13;
he contributed toward the fines levied against a fugitive slave in Wisconsin in&#13;
1855 and a fairly mysterious reference to his providing financial support to the&#13;
Underground Railroad in the Albany area in an Albany activist’s letter.Ω&#13;
Although Wadsworth and the rest of the Barnburners temporarily reentered&#13;
the Democratic fold after 1848, they left it permanently following the&#13;
Kansas-Nebraska Act. Wadsworth presided over a ‘‘Democratic-Republican&#13;
Convention’’ in July of 1856 at Syracuse, the result of which was the final&#13;
transfer of the Barnburners into the new Republican Party. Wadsworth came&#13;
close to the Republican gubernatorial nomination that year. All of these&#13;
activities would be consistent with Wadsworth’s free soil principles and his&#13;
frustration with what he saw as Southern domination of the federal government&#13;
(and his former party).∞≠&#13;
As the sectional crisis deepened in the immediate aftermath of Abraham&#13;
Lincoln’s election as president in 1860, the governor of New York appointed&#13;
James Wadsworth one of New York’s delegates to the peace conference that&#13;
met that winter in Washington in an attempt to avert civil war. The New&#13;
Yorker heard nothing as a member of the Peace Convention of 1861 that&#13;
softened his views of Southern leadership, and he refused to compromise on&#13;
the issue of slavery’s extension. L. E. Chittenden, a delegate from Vermont,&#13;
later recalled an outburst by Wadsworth, who was furious at what he saw as&#13;
Southern bad faith at the convention. According to Chittenden, the New&#13;
Yorker demanded of a Virginian delegate, ‘‘Why do you persist in your attempt&#13;
to deceive the North? You secessionists mean fight! You will keep right&#13;
on with your treasonable schemes until you either whip us or we discipline&#13;
you.’’ Although he had given up any hopes for the convention’s success,&#13;
This content downloaded from 129.174.21.5 on Thu, 17 Jun 2021 00:14:22 UTC&#13;
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms&#13;
Abolitionism as Logical Conclusion 33&#13;
Wadsworth went on to say that he would stick it out in Washington until its&#13;
conclusion: ‘‘I shall stay here until Congress adjourns on the 3d of March,&#13;
because I cannot honorably resign from the Conference. Then I shall go&#13;
home and help my people to get ready for the war in which you slaveholders&#13;
intend to involve the republic!’’∞∞&#13;
Wadsworth was certainly willing to fight, but he wanted to fight slaveholders&#13;
rather than slavery when the war began. Indeed, one of the most&#13;
explicit statements Wadsworth made on his feelings about slavery prior to the&#13;
war makes it clear that abolition was further than he was prepared to go.&#13;
In testimony to the American Freedman’s Inquiry Commission only a few&#13;
months before he died, Wadsworth claimed, ‘‘At the beginning of the war, I&#13;
was hardly a Republican. I thought slavery should be restricted to the ground&#13;
where it stood, but was opposed to interfering with it there. I dreaded insurrections,&#13;
massacres, and violence.’’∞≤&#13;
Yet it is apparent that James Wadsworth’s participation in the Civil War&#13;
reassured him on that score, so that he quickly became a champion of emancipation,&#13;
the ‘‘radical’’ position. Enlisting in the Union e√ort at the rank of&#13;
major, Wadsworth saw action at Bull Run, the first full battle of the war. After&#13;
acquitting himself admirably in the fight as a volunteer aide to the commanding&#13;
general, Irvin McDowell, Wadsworth won quick promotion to the rank&#13;
of brigadier general. Obviously, his eminence and political status were large&#13;
factors in his elevation, but Wadsworth worked diligently to be worthy of&#13;
command. During the long winter of 1861–62, when the public chafed because&#13;
the Army of the Potomac did not go on the o√ensive, Wadsworth and&#13;
his brigade were stationed at Upton’s Hill, the closest point on the Union&#13;
lines to the rebel army. There, he strove to protect the welfare of his men, but&#13;
he also became concerned for the welfare of individual slaves who came to his&#13;
attention. Some Virginian owners who had fled the Union occupation of&#13;
their region had abandoned their chattel. Wadsworth wrote to Charles Sumner,&#13;
the Republican senator from Massachusetts who was well-known for his&#13;
antislavery views, to secure his help in getting three or four families who were&#13;
‘‘practically emancipated’’ safely north. Ignoring his technical obligation to&#13;
return such ‘‘property’’ to their owners (the Fugitive Slave Law was still in&#13;
e√ect), Wadsworth helped other slaves by employing them in his camp.&#13;
No longer a faraway abstraction, slaves became an everyday presence whom&#13;
Wadsworth treated with his customary charity and pragmatism.∞≥&#13;
That pragmatic approach also caused Wadsworth to come to appreciate&#13;
the slaves he met as valuable sources of intelligence. He interviewed as many&#13;
of them as he could about the strength of the enemy forces in nearby Centerville&#13;
and Manassas, getting consistent enough answers that he became very&#13;
confident in his estimate of the size of the Confederate army, which he, along&#13;
This content downloaded from 129.174.21.5 on Thu, 17 Jun 2021 00:14:22 UTC&#13;
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms&#13;
34 Judith A. Hunter&#13;
with many other frustrated Northerners, was eager to attack. As he would&#13;
testify to Congress, ‘‘I think we are largely superior to our enemies in numbers.’’&#13;
This testimony clearly aligned Wadsworth with Republicans upset&#13;
with the overall command and approach of General George B. McClellan, a&#13;
known conservative on slavery. However, it may very well be that Wadsworth&#13;
joined the radicals’ opposition to McClellan’s policies out of personal experience&#13;
as much as political conviction. During the long period after Bull Run in&#13;
which the Army of the Potomac failed to move on the enemy, McClellan&#13;
repeatedly insisted that his army could not attack because they faced such&#13;
a huge opposing force. Wadsworth’s intelligence activities, which included&#13;
scouting and interviewing prisoners as well as refugee slaves, led him to&#13;
conclude they only faced somewhere between 40,000 and 50,000 men. He&#13;
reported this estimate up the chain of command, only to have his commander,&#13;
who was sure that the Confederates’ strength was closer to 150,000 men,&#13;
rudely dismiss Wadsworth’s conclusions. As later events showed that the&#13;
correct number was within five hundred of Wadsworth’s estimate, it is not&#13;
surprising that Wadsworth’s attitude toward McClellan became one of suspicion.∞∂&#13;
The well-known conflict between Wadsworth and McClellan in the&#13;
spring of 1862 over the number of troops left to defend Washington during&#13;
the Peninsula Campaign needs to be interpreted with the dispute of the&#13;
previous winter in mind, when Wadsworth learned to doubt McClellan’s&#13;
wisdom and judgment.&#13;
Indeed, personality issues need to be taken into account in tracing Wadsworth’s&#13;
growing radicalism, as James Wadsworth defined himself as being in&#13;
opposition to others besides ‘‘Little Mac.’’ It was a repeated pattern. Much as&#13;
his activities as a Free Soil Democrat were due to his conflict with those who&#13;
betrayed Martin Van Buren, the divisions that existed in his new party between&#13;
former Democrats and former Whigs must have influenced many of his&#13;
activities as a Republican. Wadsworth was a New York Republican who began&#13;
as a Democrat, and his relations with former Whigs in the New York party&#13;
were not always smooth. Since William Seward, the leader of that faction, was&#13;
a leading moderate in his position as Lincoln’s secretary of state, Wadsworth&#13;
may have instinctively avoided that camp. In fact, Wadsworth had actively&#13;
worked against Seward’s getting the Republican nomination in 1860, helping&#13;
to undermine the expected nominee’s viability by asserting Seward would not&#13;
be able to carry New York in the general election. Wadsworth and Seward&#13;
would hardly be inclined to become close allies once the war began.∞Σ&#13;
General Wadsworth clashed with General McClellan over his concerns&#13;
about the capital when the Army of the Potomac finally began to leave&#13;
Washington for the Peninsula Campaign because Wadsworth was now responsible&#13;
for the capital’s safety. Lincoln had appointed Wadsworth military&#13;
This content downloaded from 129.174.21.5 on Thu, 17 Jun 2021 00:14:22 UTC&#13;
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms&#13;
Abolitionism as Logical Conclusion 35&#13;
governor of the District of Columbia when he reorganized the Federal army&#13;
in March of 1862. In this capacity, Wadsworth found that he had to deal with&#13;
the legal and practical issues that immediately arose as ‘‘contrabands,’’ enemy&#13;
property in the form of slaves, showed up in Washington. At that point the&#13;
Fugitive Slave Act still bound the national government, and the Constitution&#13;
forced it to return ‘‘property’’ to owners, many of whom appealed to the&#13;
government for help in getting back their slaves. This was an awkward issue&#13;
for the Lincoln administration, particularly with Maryland slaveholders,&#13;
whose state was so important to Lincoln’s border state policies. Wadsworth&#13;
insisted that contrabands whose owners he determined to be disloyal were&#13;
under his jurisdiction, and he issued each written certificates of military&#13;
protection. But the civil authorities (usually Lincoln’s friend Marshal Ward&#13;
Lamon) disagreed and on several occasions jailed such fugitives. Wadsworth&#13;
was continually involved in bureaucratic and legal disputes on this issue, and&#13;
once he actually ordered soldiers to the jail in the middle of the night to free&#13;
all the imprisoned contrabands. The general was also responsible to some&#13;
degree for the feeding, shelter, and employment of the great numbers of&#13;
fugitive slaves in the District of Columbia, another experience that must have&#13;
helped shape his feelings on abolition. He gained a reputation as their advocate&#13;
and protector. Adam Gurowski, a Polish diarist who seemed to exist to&#13;
pass judgment on the important players in Civil War–era Washington, was&#13;
an unabashed admirer of Wadsworth’s actions (which he exaggerated as he&#13;
praised): ‘‘General Wadsworth is the good genius of the poor and oppressed&#13;
race. But for Wadsworth’s noble soul and heart the Lamons and many other&#13;
blood-hounds in Washington would have given about three-fourths of the&#13;
fugitives over to the whip of the slavers.’’∞Π&#13;
One tantalizing anecdote survives that suggests Wadsworth felt great&#13;
frustration with Lincoln’s slow movement on the issue of slavery during the&#13;
early period of the war. Adams S. Hill, a New York Tribune reporter, wrote to&#13;
his editor an account of a conversation he had one evening in July of 1862 with&#13;
the general: ‘‘He is cheerful in view of military prospects, but thinks political&#13;
signs gloomy. . . . He says that the President is not with us; has no Antislavery&#13;
instincts. He has never heard him speak of Anti-slavery men, otherwise&#13;
than as ‘radicals,’ ‘abolitionists,’ and of the ‘nigger question’ he frequently&#13;
speaks.’’ In fact, Wadsworth predicted ‘‘that if emancipation comes at all it&#13;
will be from the rebels, or in consequence of their protracting this war.’’&#13;
Although Hill never included the disgruntled New Yorker’s assessment in a&#13;
story, he nevertheless gave it great credence: ‘‘I value his testimony because he&#13;
has, as he says, been with the President and Stanton [the secretary of war]&#13;
every day at the War Department—frequently for five or six hours—during&#13;
several months.’’∞π&#13;
This content downloaded from 129.174.21.5 on Thu, 17 Jun 2021 00:14:22 UTC&#13;
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms&#13;
36 Judith A. Hunter&#13;
His experiences with fugitives seem to have given Wadsworth a spur toward&#13;
outright abolitionism, and he was relieved when Lincoln finally did&#13;
make his move against slavery with his Preliminary Emancipation Proclamation.&#13;
Yet it was his anti-Southern feelings, not any concern for African Americans,&#13;
that Wadsworth publicly spoke and wrote about when he addressed the&#13;
issue of emancipation. The New York Republicans nominated James Wadsworth&#13;
for governor in 1862, and he agreed to stand but remained serving in his&#13;
post in Washington. This arrangement meant he did little active campaigning;&#13;
when he did, he justified abolition as a means to preserve the union and punish&#13;
the South, not as an end in and of itself. He gave only one speech in New York&#13;
during the campaign, an address to a mass meeting at Cooper Union a few&#13;
days before the election, and in it he responded to Democrats’ criticisms of&#13;
Lincoln’s new emancipation policy, announced the previous month:&#13;
Mr. Lincoln has told you that he would save this country with slavery if he&#13;
could, and he would save it without slavery if he could; he has never said to&#13;
you that if he could not save slavery he would let the country go. . . . He has&#13;
said to those in rebellion against the United States: ‘‘I give you 100 days to&#13;
return to your allegiance; if you fail to do that, I will strike from under you&#13;
that institution which some of you seem to think dearer than life, than liberty,&#13;
than country, than peace.’’ . . . Gentlemen, I stand by Abraham Lincoln.&#13;
[Tremendous applause.] It is just, it is holy so to do.∞∫&#13;
Although it would be politically prudent to omit any concern for the&#13;
injustice of slavery when speaking to voters of a city that would see horrific&#13;
race riots within a year, prudence was not a quality Wadsworth possessed. In&#13;
the same speech he at last embraced the label ‘‘abolitionist’’ for the first time.&#13;
Finally reaching this conclusion was consistent with his sense of honor and&#13;
his sense of where the slave power and the war had brought the nation.&#13;
I know, for I have sometimes felt, the influence of the odium which the&#13;
spurious aristocracy, who have so largely directed the destinies of this nation&#13;
for three-quarters of a century, have attached to the word ‘‘abolition.’’ They&#13;
have treated it, and too often taught us to treat it, as some low, vulgar crime,&#13;
not to be spoken of in good society or mentioned in fashionable parlors. I&#13;
know there are many men still influenced by this prejudice; but let those who,&#13;
in this hour of peril, this struggle of life and death, shrink from that odium&#13;
stand aside. The events of this hour are too big for them.∞Ω&#13;
In the end, Wadsworth lost the race by fewer than eleven thousand votes,&#13;
despite many handicaps. He was almost totally absent from the hustings. The&#13;
absence of New York soldiers at the front (a significant potential voting bloc&#13;
in his favor) must have harmed his chances even more, as did the fact that&#13;
This content downloaded from 129.174.21.5 on Thu, 17 Jun 2021 00:14:22 UTC&#13;
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms&#13;
Abolitionism as Logical Conclusion 37&#13;
McClellan refused to use the Army of the Potomac to follow up on the&#13;
victory at Antietam. Finally, the lack of real support from New York kingmakers&#13;
William Seward and Thurlow Weed was likely the most important&#13;
blow. Gideon Welles, Lincoln’s secretary of the navy, recalled in his diary the&#13;
fatal New York infighting that had defeated Wadsworth when he lamented&#13;
his death in 1864: ‘‘He should, by good right and fair-dealing, have been at&#13;
this moment Governor of New York, but the perfidy of Thurlow Weed and&#13;
others defeated him. I have always believed that Seward was, if not implicated,&#13;
a sympathizer in that business.’’≤≠&#13;
James Wadsworth finally converted to abolitionism because he saw it as an&#13;
e√ective war measure. As he told supporters who came to see him shortly&#13;
after his nomination,&#13;
I have never failed, gentlemen, previous to the outbreak of this rebellion . . . to&#13;
declare my earnest devotion to the Constitution of the United States, and my&#13;
desire to uphold it, with what are called compromises and concessions on&#13;
behalf of Slavery. But, gentlemen, Secession and War, bloody and relentless&#13;
war, have changed our relations to that which is the cause and the source of&#13;
the war. . . . We have the right, we are bound, moreover, by the most solemn&#13;
obligations of duty, to use this agency [emancipation], so far as we can, to put&#13;
an end to this struggle, and to save the lives of white men who are perishing by&#13;
thousands in this country.&#13;
Unfortunately for his political career, Wadsworth came to accept this fact&#13;
before the bulk of the Northern electorate did (1862 was a poor year for many&#13;
Republican candidates). Yet the argument that emancipation diminished the&#13;
Southern capacity to wage rebellion ultimately did largely win over skeptical&#13;
Northern opinion. They simply did not arrive at that point as quickly as&#13;
Wadsworth did.≤∞&#13;
The anger at the South that prodded James S. Wadsworth along the path&#13;
to abolitionism, though, creates a paradox. In his Washington speech, the&#13;
general-turned-candidate touched on a theme that was a constant refrain in&#13;
his wartime correspondence:&#13;
How long are we to bear the insolence of this Southern aristocracy? Have we&#13;
not borne it long enough? Has it not long enough disturbed and distracted&#13;
our councils, and paralyzed our energies? Has it not long enough paralyzed&#13;
the energies of the country? Nay, more, has it not long enough, in the eyes of&#13;
the other civilized nations of the world, covered us with infamy?&#13;
Wadsworth used the term ‘‘aristocracy’’ with real distaste here and elsewhere,&#13;
yet there were few Americans with a more aristocratic pedigree than&#13;
his. Besides his great wealth and illustrious ancestry, one fact from his biogra-&#13;
This content downloaded from 129.174.21.5 on Thu, 17 Jun 2021 00:14:22 UTC&#13;
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms&#13;
38 Judith A. Hunter&#13;
phy that goes far to prove his own qualifications as an aristocrat would be that&#13;
he built his impressive home, Hartford House, after he returned from his&#13;
multiyear honeymoon abroad, exactly on the plans of the estate of Britain’s&#13;
Lord Hertford, which he and his wife had visited and admired. Yet his zeal&#13;
for the war e√ort and his support for abolition rested on republican distaste&#13;
for the South’s slave-owning class. Wadsworth followed his questions about&#13;
those Southerner aristocrats to his Washington supporters with the statement,&#13;
‘‘We are in the pangs of dissolution, or we are in the pangs of exorcism.&#13;
If we would save ourselves, we must cast out the devil which has tormented&#13;
and disgraced us from the hour of our national birth.’’ To James S. Wadsworth&#13;
the devil was not slavery; it was the aristocracy of the South. Because&#13;
abolition would prevent the Southern aristocracy from ever endangering the&#13;
nation again, Wadsworth ended his life as an avowed abolitionist.≤≤&#13;
Notes&#13;
1. John Hay, Lincoln and the Civil War in the Diaries and Letters of John Hay, ed.&#13;
Tyler Dennett (New York: Dodd, Mead, and Co., 1939; reprint, New York: Da Capo&#13;
Press, 1988), 182.&#13;
2. James Wadsworth has been the subject of three biographies, none of which&#13;
analyzes his changing politics: Henry Greenleaf Pearson, James S. Wadsworth of Geneseo:&#13;
Brevet Major-General, U.S.V. (New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1913); John F.&#13;
Krumwiede, ‘‘Old Waddy’s Coming’’: The Military Career of Brigadier General James S.&#13;
Wadsworth, Army of the Potomac Series (Baltimore: Butternut and Blue, 2002);&#13;
Wayne Mahood, General Wadsworth: The Life and Times of Brevet Major General&#13;
James S. Wadsworth (Cambridge, MA: Da Capo Press, 2003).&#13;
3. The concept of the ‘‘slave power’’ is best set out in David Brion Davis, The Slave&#13;
Power Conspiracy and the Paranoid Style (Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University&#13;
Press, 1969). One could make a fascinating comparison between Wadsworth’s antislavery&#13;
career and that of a true radical on the subject, Gerrit Smith’s. Both men had&#13;
immense fortunes in upstate New York real estate (Wadsworth in the Genesee Valley&#13;
and Smith’s in the Utica area), and both men ended up as abolitionists. Yet Smith was&#13;
a vital leader of the ‘‘burned-over district’s’’ antislavery movement from the 1830s,&#13;
active in the single-issue Liberty Party (and elected to Congress), and he ultimately&#13;
went so far in his e√orts to eradicate slavery that he provided financial support for&#13;
John Brown’s raid on Harper’s Ferry. See Ralph Volney Harlow, Gerrit Smith: Philanthropist&#13;
and Reformer (New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1939; reprint, New&#13;
York: Russell and Russell, 1972). Wadsworth never got near to the abolitionist wing of&#13;
the antislavery spectrum before the Civil War.&#13;
4. James S. Wadsworth to Martin Van Buren, June 1, 1844, Presidential Papers&#13;
Microfilm, Martin Van Martin Buren Papers, Series 2: 1844 May 30 to 1845 May 7, reel&#13;
29; Pearson, James S. Wadsworth of Geneseo, 35–37; Michael F. Holt, The Fate of Their&#13;
Country: Politicians, Slavery Extension, and the Coming of the Civil War (New York:&#13;
Hill and Wang, 2004), 11.&#13;
This content downloaded from 129.174.21.5 on Thu, 17 Jun 2021 00:14:22 UTC&#13;
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms&#13;
Abolitionism as Logical Conclusion 39&#13;
5. Wadsworth to Van Buren, June 1, 1844; Mahood, General Wadsworth, 46; Lockwood&#13;
L. Doty, A History of Livingston County, New York: From Its Earliest Traditions,&#13;
to Its Part in the War for Our Union (Geneseo, NY: Edward E. Doty, 1876), 528. In a&#13;
truly ironic footnote, Birney ended up being reinterred by his wife alongside other&#13;
members of her family in a small cemetery just down the road from Wadsworth’s&#13;
birthplace in Geneseo. Betty Fladeland, James Gillespie Birney: Slaveholder to Abolitionist&#13;
(Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1955), 293n.&#13;
6. Jonathan H. Earle, Jacksonian Antislavery and the Politics of Free Soil, 1824–1854&#13;
(Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2004), chap. 2. The best overview&#13;
of the ‘‘burned-over district’’ of New York remains Whitney Cross, The Burned-Over&#13;
District: The Social and Intellectual History of Enthusiastic Religion in Western New&#13;
York, 1800–1850 (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1950). Cross, however, does not&#13;
include Wadsworth’s Livingston County in his discussion, as he feels the role of&#13;
Wadsworth and his father as landlord for so much of the county made it di√erent&#13;
from other areas he discusses. Yet work that has been done on Livingston County&#13;
since the publication of Cross’s work suggests that it was very much like the rest of the&#13;
burned-over district. For example, Virginia Nestlen finds that the local Presbyterian&#13;
church experienced a significant revival episode: see Virginia Nestlen, ‘‘Revival in&#13;
1825: The Role of the Wadsworth Family in Geneseo’’ (honors thesis, State University&#13;
of New York at Geneseo, 1998).&#13;
7. Henry B. Stanton, Random Recollections (New York: Harper and Brothers,&#13;
1887), 160; John Niven, Martin Van Buren: The Romantic Age of American Politics (New&#13;
York: Oxford University Press, 1983), 574.&#13;
8. Pearson, James S. Wadsworth of Geneseo, 40–42; Francis Preston Blair to James&#13;
S. Wadsworth, June 28, 1848, Wadsworth Family Papers, Library of Congress, Washington,&#13;
DC.&#13;
9. Pearson, James S. Wadsworth of Geneseo, 29; Frank A. Abial, History of the&#13;
Republican Party, Embracing Its Origin, Growth and Mission (Springfield, IL: Union&#13;
Publishing Company, 1884), 126; Tom Carlaco, The Underground Railroad in the&#13;
Adirondack Region ( Je√erson, NC: McFarland and Company, 2004), 191.&#13;
10. Pearson, James S. Wadsworth of Geneseo, 45–47.&#13;
11. Mahood, General Wadsworth, 58–59; L. E. Chittenden, Personal Reminiscences,&#13;
1840–1890 (New York: Richmond, Croscup and Co., 1893), 303.&#13;
12. ‘‘Testimony of a War Department Special Inspector,’’ in Ira Berlin et al., eds.,&#13;
The Wartime Genesis of Free Labor: The Lower South, Freedom: A Documentary&#13;
History of Emancipation 1861–1867, series 1, vol. 3 (Cambridge: Cambridge University&#13;
Press, 1990), 492.&#13;
13. Pearson, James S. Wadsworth of Geneseo, 95–97; Mahood, General Wadsworth,&#13;
69–74.&#13;
14. Pearson, James S. Wadsworth of Geneseo, 97, 99, 101, 104, 105; Edwin C. Fishel,&#13;
The Secret War for the Union: The Untold Story of Military Intelligence in the Civil&#13;
War (Boston: Houghton MiΔin Company, 1996), 112, 113, 129; James M. McPherson,&#13;
Ordeal by Fire: The Civil War and Reconstruction (New York: Alfred A. Knopf,&#13;
1982), 212.&#13;
This content downloaded from 129.174.21.5 on Thu, 17 Jun 2021 00:14:22 UTC&#13;
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms&#13;
40 Judith A. Hunter&#13;
15. Eric Foner, Free Soil, Free Labor, Free Men: The Ideology of the Republican Party&#13;
before the Civil War (New York: Oxford University Press, 1970), 182.&#13;
16. Pearson, James S. Wadsworth of Geneseo, 46, 48, 134–41; Margaret Leech,&#13;
Reveille in Washington, 1860–1865 (New York: Harper and Brother Publishers, 1941),&#13;
247; Don E. Fehrenbacher, The Slaveholding Republic: An Account of the United States&#13;
Government’s Relations to Slavery, ed. Ward M. McAfee (New York: Oxford University&#13;
Press, 2001), 249; Allen C. Guelzo, Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation: The&#13;
End of Slavery in America (New York: Simon and Schuster, 2004), 89–90; Adam&#13;
Gurowski, Diary from March 4, 1861 to November 12, 1862 (Boston: Lee and Shepard,&#13;
1862), 246.&#13;
17. Adams S. Hill to Sydney Howard Gay, quoted in James Ford Rhodes, History&#13;
of the United States from the Compromise of 1850 to the Final Restoration of Home Rule at&#13;
the South in 1877, vol. 4, 1862–1864 (New York: Macmillan Company, 1913), 64n.&#13;
Rhodes indicates that he is quoting ‘‘private correspondence which has been kindly&#13;
placed at my disposal by Professor Hill.’’&#13;
18. Speech of James S. Wadsworth at the Cooper Union, New York City, Oct. 30,&#13;
1862, ‘‘compiled from the reports in New York papers of October 31’’ and reprinted in&#13;
Pearson, James S. Wadsworth of Geneseo, 158–63, quotation on 160.&#13;
19. Ibid.&#13;
20. Ibid., 158–63, quotation on 160; Gideon Welles, Diary of Gideon Welles, 3 vols.&#13;
(Boston: Houghton and MiΔin Company, 1911), 2:27. For an overview of the 1862&#13;
gubernatorial race, see Stewart Mitchell, Horatio Seymour of New York (Cambridge:&#13;
Harvard University Press, 1938), chap. 12; Mahood, General Wadsworth, chap. 11;&#13;
Pearson, James S. Wadsworth of Geneseo, chap. 5.&#13;
21. ‘‘Speech of General Wadsworth at Washington, Friday Evening, September&#13;
26, 1862,’’ Genesee Valley Collection, Milne Library, State University of New York–&#13;
Geneseo.&#13;
22. Ibid.; Mahood, General Wadsworth, 34.&#13;
This content downloaded from 129.174.21.5 on Thu, 17 Jun 2021 00:14:22 UTC&#13;
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms</text>
          </elementText>
        </elementTextContainer>
      </element>
    </elementContainer>
  </itemType>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="1265">
              <text>Abolitionism as Logical Conclusion: General James S. Wadsworth as a Case Study in Anti-Southern Sentiment and the Radicalizing Experience of the Civil War</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="49">
          <name>Subject</name>
          <description>The topic of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="1266">
              <text>Essays on Sectional Conflict, the Civil War, and the Long Reconstruction</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="41">
          <name>Description</name>
          <description>An account of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="1267">
              <text>General James Wadsworth and his actions as an abolitionist and radical Republican</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="39">
          <name>Creator</name>
          <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="1268">
              <text>Judith A. Hunter</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="48">
          <name>Source</name>
          <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="1269">
              <text>JSTOR&#13;
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt6wrmq5.6</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="45">
          <name>Publisher</name>
          <description>An entity responsible for making the resource available</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="1270">
              <text>University of Virginia Press</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="40">
          <name>Date</name>
          <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="1271">
              <text>2011</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="47">
          <name>Rights</name>
          <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="1272">
              <text>Public Domain</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="194">
      <name>abolitionism</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="48">
      <name>General James Wadsworth</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="195">
      <name>Radical Republican</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
